KVM Lock Overview

1. Acquisition Orders

The acquisition orders for mutexes are as follows:

  • cpus_read_lock() is taken outside kvm_lock

  • kvm_usage_lock is taken outside cpus_read_lock()

  • kvm->lock is taken outside vcpu->mutex

  • kvm->lock is taken outside kvm->slots_lock and kvm->irq_lock

  • kvm->slots_lock is taken outside kvm->irq_lock, though acquiring them together is quite rare.

  • kvm->mn_active_invalidate_count ensures that pairs of invalidate_range_start() and invalidate_range_end() callbacks use the same memslots array. kvm->slots_lock and kvm->slots_arch_lock are taken on the waiting side when modifying memslots, so MMU notifiers must not take either kvm->slots_lock or kvm->slots_arch_lock.

cpus_read_lock() vs kvm_lock:

  • Taking cpus_read_lock() outside of kvm_lock is problematic, despite that being the official ordering, as it is quite easy to unknowingly trigger cpus_read_lock() while holding kvm_lock. Use caution when walking vm_list, e.g. avoid complex operations when possible.

For SRCU:

  • synchronize_srcu(&kvm->srcu) is called inside critical sections for kvm->lock, vcpu->mutex and kvm->slots_lock. These locks _cannot_ be taken inside a kvm->srcu read-side critical section; that is, the following is broken:

    srcu_read_lock(&kvm->srcu);
mutex_lock(&kvm->slots_lock);

  • kvm->slots_arch_lock instead is released before the call to synchronize_srcu(). It _can_ therefore be taken inside a kvm->srcu read-side critical section, for example while processing a vmexit.

On x86:

  • vcpu->mutex is taken outside kvm->arch.hyperv.hv_lock and kvm->arch.xen.xen_lock

  • kvm->arch.mmu_lock is an rwlock; critical sections for kvm->arch.tdp_mmu_pages_lock and kvm->arch.mmu_unsync_pages_lock must also take kvm->arch.mmu_lock

Everything else is a leaf: no other lock is taken inside the critical sections.

2. Exception

Fast page fault:

Fast page fault is the fast path which fixes the guest page fault out of the mmu-lock on x86. Currently, the page fault can be fast in one of the following two cases:

  1. Access Tracking: The SPTE is not present, but it is marked for access tracking. That means we need to restore the saved R/X bits. This is described in more detail later below.

  2. Write-Protection: The SPTE is present and the fault is caused by write-protect. That means we just need to change the W bit of the spte.

What we use to avoid all the races is the Host-writable bit and MMU-writable bit on the spte:

  • Host-writable means the gfn is writable in the host kernel page tables and in its KVM memslot.

  • MMU-writable means the gfn is writable in the guest’s mmu and it is not write-protected by shadow page write-protection.

On fast page fault path, we will use cmpxchg to atomically set the spte W bit if spte.HOST_WRITEABLE = 1 and spte.WRITE_PROTECT = 1, to restore the saved R/X bits if for an access-traced spte, or both. This is safe because whenever changing these bits can be detected by cmpxchg.

But we need carefully check these cases:

  1. The mapping from gfn to pfn

The mapping from gfn to pfn may be changed since we can only ensure the pfn is not changed during cmpxchg. This is a ABA problem, for example, below case will happen:

At the beginning:

gpte = gfn1
gfn1 is mapped to pfn1 on host
spte is the shadow page table entry corresponding with gpte and
spte = pfn1

On fast page fault path:

CPU 0:

CPU 1:

 
old_spte = *spte;

pfn1 is swapped out:

spte = 0;

pfn1 is re-alloced for gfn2.

gpte is changed to point to gfn2 by the guest:

spte = pfn1;

if (cmpxchg(spte, old_spte, old_spte+W)
    mark_page_dirty(vcpu->kvm, gfn1)
         OOPS!!!

We dirty-log for gfn1, that means gfn2 is lost in dirty-bitmap.

For direct sp, we can easily avoid it since the spte of direct sp is fixed to gfn. For indirect sp, we disabled fast page fault for simplicity.

A solution for indirect sp could be to pin the gfn before the cmpxchg. After the pinning:

  • We have held the refcount of pfn; that means the pfn can not be freed and be reused for another gfn.

  • The pfn is writable and therefore it cannot be shared between different gfns by KSM.

Then, we can ensure the dirty bitmaps is correctly set for a gfn.

  1. Dirty bit tracking

In the original code, the spte can be fast updated (non-atomically) if the spte is read-only and the Accessed bit has already been set since the Accessed bit and Dirty bit can not be lost.

But it is not true after fast page fault since the spte can be marked writable between reading spte and updating spte. Like below case:

At the beginning:

spte.W = 0
spte.Accessed = 1

CPU 0:

CPU 1:

In mmu_spte_update():

old_spte = *spte;


/* 'if' condition is satisfied. */
if (old_spte.Accessed == 1 &&
     old_spte.W == 0)
   spte = new_spte;

on fast page fault path:

spte.W = 1

memory write on the spte:

spte.Dirty = 1

else
  old_spte = xchg(spte, new_spte);
if (old_spte.Accessed &&
    !new_spte.Accessed)
  flush = true;
if (old_spte.Dirty &&
    !new_spte.Dirty)
  flush = true;
  OOPS!!!

The Dirty bit is lost in this case.

In order to avoid this kind of issue, we always treat the spte as “volatile” if it can be updated out of mmu-lock [see spte_has_volatile_bits()]; it means the spte is always atomically updated in this case.

  1. flush tlbs due to spte updated

If the spte is updated from writable to read-only, we should flush all TLBs, otherwise rmap_write_protect will find a read-only spte, even though the writable spte might be cached on a CPU’s TLB.

As mentioned before, the spte can be updated to writable out of mmu-lock on fast page fault path. In order to easily audit the path, we see if TLBs needing to be flushed caused this reason in mmu_spte_update() since this is a common function to update spte (present -> present).

Since the spte is “volatile” if it can be updated out of mmu-lock, we always atomically update the spte and the race caused by fast page fault can be avoided. See the comments in spte_has_volatile_bits() and mmu_spte_update().

Lockless Access Tracking:

This is used for Intel CPUs that are using EPT but do not support the EPT A/D bits. In this case, PTEs are tagged as A/D disabled (using ignored bits), and when the KVM MMU notifier is called to track accesses to a page (via kvm_mmu_notifier_clear_flush_young), it marks the PTE not-present in hardware by clearing the RWX bits in the PTE and storing the original R & X bits in more unused/ignored bits. When the VM tries to access the page later on, a fault is generated and the fast page fault mechanism described above is used to atomically restore the PTE to a Present state. The W bit is not saved when the PTE is marked for access tracking and during restoration to the Present state, the W bit is set depending on whether or not it was a write access. If it wasn’t, then the W bit will remain clear until a write access happens, at which time it will be set using the Dirty tracking mechanism described above.

3. Reference

kvm_lock

Type:

mutex

Arch:

any

Protects:

  • vm_list

kvm_usage_lock

Type:

mutex

Arch:

any

Protects:

  • kvm_usage_count

  • hardware virtualization enable/disable

Comment:

Exists to allow taking cpus_read_lock() while kvm_usage_count is protected, which simplifies the virtualization enabling logic.

kvm->mn_invalidate_lock

Type:

spinlock_t

Arch:

any

Protects:

mn_active_invalidate_count, mn_memslots_update_rcuwait

kvm_arch::tsc_write_lock

Type:

raw_spinlock_t

Arch:

x86

Protects:

  • kvm_arch::{last_tsc_write,last_tsc_nsec,last_tsc_offset}

  • tsc offset in vmcb

Comment:

‘raw’ because updating the tsc offsets must not be preempted.

kvm->mmu_lock

Type:

spinlock_t or rwlock_t

Arch:

any

Protects:

-shadow page/shadow tlb entry

Comment:

it is a spinlock since it is used in mmu notifier.

kvm->srcu

Type:

srcu lock

Arch:

any

Protects:

  • kvm->memslots

  • kvm->buses

Comment:

The srcu read lock must be held while accessing memslots (e.g. when using gfn_to_* functions) and while accessing in-kernel MMIO/PIO address->device structure mapping (kvm->buses). The srcu index can be stored in kvm_vcpu->srcu_idx per vcpu if it is needed by multiple functions.

kvm->slots_arch_lock

Type:

mutex

Arch:

any (only needed on x86 though)

Protects:

any arch-specific fields of memslots that have to be modified in a kvm->srcu read-side critical section.

Comment:

must be held before reading the pointer to the current memslots, until after all changes to the memslots are complete

wakeup_vcpus_on_cpu_lock

Type:

spinlock_t

Arch:

x86

Protects:

wakeup_vcpus_on_cpu

Comment:

This is a per-CPU lock and it is used for VT-d posted-interrupts. When VT-d posted-interrupts are supported and the VM has assigned devices, we put the blocked vCPU on the list blocked_vcpu_on_cpu protected by blocked_vcpu_on_cpu_lock. When VT-d hardware issues wakeup notification event since external interrupts from the assigned devices happens, we will find the vCPU on the list to wakeup.

vendor_module_lock

Type:

mutex

Arch:

x86

Protects:

loading a vendor module (kvm_amd or kvm_intel)

Comment:

Exists because using kvm_lock leads to deadlock. kvm_lock is taken in notifiers, e.g. __kvmclock_cpufreq_notifier(), that may be invoked while cpu_hotplug_lock is held, e.g. from cpufreq_boost_trigger_state(), and many operations need to take cpu_hotplug_lock when loading a vendor module, e.g. updating static calls.